@DailyNation

Secession dilemma: How Africa got here and why the debate sparks controversy worldwide

11 months ago, 12 Jan 22:15

By: Maria Nzomo

Globally, secessionist movements and trends are as old as the history of the state system. Some scholars date it to the ancient Greek city states. Others date it to the period of the French Revolution, when the concept gained currency and became a major rallying point for statehood and sovereignty. Over the centuries, as societies and political economies have evolved and acquired more structured governance systems, so have the people of the world become more assertive in demanding, exercising and guarding their perceived basic rights, entitlements and freedoms against any form of infringement. In Africa, the increasing frequency of identity-based conflicts and secessionist movements can be traced to the first “Scramble for Africa” which began with the Berlin Conference of 1884 and completed by 1914. This had enormous long-term impact on the pre-colonial, colonial and post-colonial African communities and political entities that found themselves arbitrarily partitioned by European colonisers. They became spheres of influence, protectorates, colonies and free-trade areas, with no consideration of the existing political geography and ethnic and cultural composition of the colonised. SPLIT As a result, most African countries have significant fractions of their communities split between two or three countries. For example, the Maasai are split between Kenya (62 per cent) and Tanzania (38 per cent) and the Chewa between Mozambique (50 per cent), Malawi (34 per cent), and Zimbabwe (16 per cent). Political historians and anthropological scholars have noted that there are about 231 ethnic groups in Africa, with at least 10 per cent of their historical homelands falling into more than one country. Conscious that the boundary issue could later raise political problems, the founding fathers of the Organisation of African Unity (OAU ) and its Charter in 1963, made a legally-binding decision to uphold the colonially-inherited borders of post-colonial states, making them sacrosanct and not to be tampered with. Further, they ensured that this legal decision became part of international law and defined relations among African states. Despite their arbitrariness, these boundaries endured in the post-colonial era, but are increasingly being challenged; thus raising fundamental questions of the legitimacy of the post-colonial state. UNHAPPY CONDITION As the curtains fell on 2017, there were many in Africa and around the world who were dissatisfied with their governments, which they blame for their unhappy condition. The 21st century and its information technology-driven globalisation, has facilitated the enormous pressure being put on governments and other institutions to democratise and uphold justice for all; become more inclusive and uphold the rule of law. More often than not, governments are unable or unwilling to respond as expected to the perceived entitlements demanded by concerned citizens. The response to the ensuing sense of deprivation, exclusion and violation, may elicit several possible types of reactions; one of which is the desire to withdraw from the body polity to which the aggrieved persons belong and seek an alternative space for self-determination. Herein lie many of the secessionist tendencies, whether fully realised or not. The concept of “secession” remains highly-contested both in ...
Read More


Category: oped opinion topnews news

Suggested

17 hours ago, 13:08
@TheEastAfrican - By: Charles Onyango-o ...
EAC, just let Burundi go, we can always remarry

One can see Kenya and Uganda squabbling, but at least they are easily reconcilable. ...

Category: topnews news oped opinion
15 hours ago, 14:42
@DailyNation - By: John Walubengo
M-Pesa is a critical resource that should never fail

The regulator must demand more system security measures from M-Pesa and the service provide should treat customers better in times of distress. ...

Category: oped opinion news
16 hours ago, 13:47
@DailyNation - By: Bitange Ndemo
Let’s embrace evidence-based policymaking

With big data, rationality will replace popularity in public policy. ...

Category: oped opinion news
1 day ago, 06:08
@TheStar - By: Adhere Cavince
ADHERE CAVINCE: Kenya can bridge China trade deficit

While relations between African countries and China have deepened and broadened in various fronts, some observers see the latter as the chief beneficiary. Key fodder for the pessimism partly arises fr ...

Category: oped opinion news topnews
1 day ago, 22:59
@DailyNation - By: Kaltum Guyo
Politicians’ greed undermines equality and security in society

The accumulation of wealth by a small minority undermines the work of the government. ...

Category: topnews news oped opinion
1 day ago, 22:59
@DailyNation - By: Constance De Leus ...
Internet shutdowns cost us a lot and smother critical freedoms

The internet lets us connect, share and explore our human potential. ...

Category: topnews news oped opinion

@DailyNation

Secession dilemma: How Africa got here and why the debate sparks controversy worldwide

11 months ago, 12 Jan 22:15

By: Maria Nzomo
Globally, secessionist movements and trends are as old as the history of the state system. Some scholars date it to the ancient Greek city states. Others date it to the period of the French Revolution, when the concept gained currency and became a major rallying point for statehood and sovereignty. Over the centuries, as societies and political economies have evolved and acquired more structured governance systems, so have the people of the world become more assertive in demanding, exercising and guarding their perceived basic rights, entitlements and freedoms against any form of infringement. In Africa, the increasing frequency of identity-based conflicts and secessionist movements can be traced to the first “Scramble for Africa” which began with the Berlin Conference of 1884 and completed by 1914. This had enormous long-term impact on the pre-colonial, colonial and post-colonial African communities and political entities that found themselves arbitrarily partitioned by European colonisers. They became spheres of influence, protectorates, colonies and free-trade areas, with no consideration of the existing political geography and ethnic and cultural composition of the colonised. SPLIT As a result, most African countries have significant fractions of their communities split between two or three countries. For example, the Maasai are split between Kenya (62 per cent) and Tanzania (38 per cent) and the Chewa between Mozambique (50 per cent), Malawi (34 per cent), and Zimbabwe (16 per cent). Political historians and anthropological scholars have noted that there are about 231 ethnic groups in Africa, with at least 10 per cent of their historical homelands falling into more than one country. Conscious that the boundary issue could later raise political problems, the founding fathers of the Organisation of African Unity (OAU ) and its Charter in 1963, made a legally-binding decision to uphold the colonially-inherited borders of post-colonial states, making them sacrosanct and not to be tampered with. Further, they ensured that this legal decision became part of international law and defined relations among African states. Despite their arbitrariness, these boundaries endured in the post-colonial era, but are increasingly being challenged; thus raising fundamental questions of the legitimacy of the post-colonial state. UNHAPPY CONDITION As the curtains fell on 2017, there were many in Africa and around the world who were dissatisfied with their governments, which they blame for their unhappy condition. The 21st century and its information technology-driven globalisation, has facilitated the enormous pressure being put on governments and other institutions to democratise and uphold justice for all; become more inclusive and uphold the rule of law. More often than not, governments are unable or unwilling to respond as expected to the perceived entitlements demanded by concerned citizens. The response to the ensuing sense of deprivation, exclusion and violation, may elicit several possible types of reactions; one of which is the desire to withdraw from the body polity to which the aggrieved persons belong and seek an alternative space for self-determination. Herein lie many of the secessionist tendencies, whether fully realised or not. The concept of “secession” remains highly-contested both in ...
Read More

Category: oped opinion topnews news

Suggested

17 hours ago, 13:08
@TheEastAfrican - By: Charles Onyango-o ...
EAC, just let Burundi go, we can always remarry

One can see Kenya and Uganda squabbling, but at least they are easily reconcilable. ...

Category: topnews news oped opinion
15 hours ago, 14:42
@DailyNation - By: John Walubengo
M-Pesa is a critical resource that should never fail

The regulator must demand more system security measures from M-Pesa and the service provide should treat customers better in times of distress. ...

Category: oped opinion news
16 hours ago, 13:47
@DailyNation - By: Bitange Ndemo
Let’s embrace evidence-based policymaking

With big data, rationality will replace popularity in public policy. ...

Category: oped opinion news
1 day ago, 06:08
@TheStar - By: Adhere Cavince
ADHERE CAVINCE: Kenya can bridge China trade deficit

While relations between African countries and China have deepened and broadened in various fronts, some observers see the latter as the chief beneficiary. Key fodder for the pessimism partly arises fr ...

Category: oped opinion news topnews
1 day ago, 22:59
@DailyNation - By: Kaltum Guyo
Politicians’ greed undermines equality and security in society

The accumulation of wealth by a small minority undermines the work of the government. ...

Category: topnews news oped opinion
1 day ago, 22:59
@DailyNation - By: Constance De Leus ...
Internet shutdowns cost us a lot and smother critical freedoms

The internet lets us connect, share and explore our human potential. ...

Category: topnews news oped opinion
Our App