@BusinessDaily

OWINO: Why rate cap law was a tragic gamble

4 months ago, 17 Maý 07:01

By: Kwame Owino

On September 14, 2016, the Banking (Amendment) Act 2016 came into force, imposing a cap on lending and deposit rates.

One month earlier, lawmakers had passed the amendment, hailing it as a sage move that would see benefits accrue to small and medium enterprises (SMEs) in the form of affordable loans.

The prevailing wisdom was that the government would — at the stroke of a pen — give more cake for consumers.

That credit would dry up for small private borrowers was an outcome that needed no economic mystic-analyst types to proclaim.

In implicit opposition to the cap, CFC Stanbic Bank regional economist Jibran Qureishi, Robert Shaw and many others sang a plain, well-worn chorus — the cap will lead banks away from lending to small borrowers.

More damage was wrought when the government continued to borrow heavily from the very same market it sought to create for the private borrower, depriving the economy of credit and growth.

The government effectively offered cake to the public with one hand and then gobbled it up with the other, leaving stomachs growling.

MORE: Banks to put a risk premium on loans in cap law change - VIDEO

Desired effect

A year on, President Uhuru Kenyatta — whose signature brought the law into effect — reversed the conviction he shared with the legislature, conceding that the amendment did not have the desired effect.

The adverse effects of caps on small borrowers come as no surprise. It is a globally documented phenomenon.

This reversal must leave the public questioning the insights that drove the decision to implement an interest rate cap, the advisers that proposed it and the depth of considerations made by the executive before signing it into law.

Banks play an important intermediary role in the economy by connecting those who have cash and are in want of investment opportunities to those who are or could be engaged in productive economic activities but do not have the financial wherewithal.

The banks ‘buy’ deposits and ‘sell’ loans, earning the difference. Those deposits and loans are bought and sold at an ‘interest rate’.

Additionally, the buyers of those loans are businesses and the government.

The government is a less risky borrower than the small businesses and also has the capacity to be a bigger player in the loan market than several businesses put together.

If the government and many small businesses competed for loans at the same interest rates, banks will prefer to lend to the government.

Tracking borrowers

Because banks spend a lot of time and money vetting and tracking borrowers, they will prefer to lend to the government even if both the small businesses and the government were paying the same interest rates.

As the cap came into force, the government gave the verbal signal that it would stay away from the domestic credit market and then did the opposite by increasing its domestic borrowing.

The effect was that the interest rate cap made it difficult for the SMEs, in whose name the law was enacted, ...
Read More


Category: business news lifestyle corporate markets economy opinion

Suggested

11 hours ago, 00:07
@StandardMedia - By: Lee Mwiti
State offers to make refunds on housing tax

CS assures those who do not qualify for houses under proposed State plan that they will get back their contributions. ...

Category: business news
1 hours ago, 10:23
@BusinessDaily - By: Galgallo Fayo
Embattled UNEP head refunds travel expenses

The Unep boss makes clear his intention to stay put, insisting that he will accept personal responsibility . ...

Category: business news
1 hours ago, 10:12
@BusinessDaily - By: Galgallo Fayo
Karume estate in deeper trouble

KRA issued the Jacaranda Hotels Limited with an enforcement notice on January 12, seeking immediate payment of tax arrears amounting to Sh197 million. ...

Category: business news lifestyle markets
Now
@BusinessDaily - By: Victor Juma
Uhuru hits consumers with more hidden taxes

Tough times ahead as it emerges that President’s memo included an array of new and higher levies expected to significantly raise the cost of living. ...

Category: business news opinion lifestyle
11 hours ago, 00:07
@StandardMedia - By: Moses Omusolo
Vivo wraps up Engen deal for Sh20 billion

Pact will see firm take over rival’s outlets in eight countries, including Kenya. ...

Category: business news
17 hours ago, 18:15
@BusinessDaily - By: Brian Ngugi
Uhuru slaps M-Pesa with 66pc mobile cash tax rise

The cost of sending money through mobile services such as Safaricom’s M-Pesa will increase further after President Uhuru Kenyatta proposed to raise tax on the services from 12 per cent to 20 per ...

Category: business news

@BusinessDaily

OWINO: Why rate cap law was a tragic gamble

4 months ago, 17 Maý 07:01

By: Kwame Owino

On September 14, 2016, the Banking (Amendment) Act 2016 came into force, imposing a cap on lending and deposit rates.

One month earlier, lawmakers had passed the amendment, hailing it as a sage move that would see benefits accrue to small and medium enterprises (SMEs) in the form of affordable loans.

The prevailing wisdom was that the government would — at the stroke of a pen — give more cake for consumers.

That credit would dry up for small private borrowers was an outcome that needed no economic mystic-analyst types to proclaim.

In implicit opposition to the cap, CFC Stanbic Bank regional economist Jibran Qureishi, Robert Shaw and many others sang a plain, well-worn chorus — the cap will lead banks away from lending to small borrowers.

More damage was wrought when the government continued to borrow heavily from the very same market it sought to create for the private borrower, depriving the economy of credit and growth.

The government effectively offered cake to the public with one hand and then gobbled it up with the other, leaving stomachs growling.

MORE: Banks to put a risk premium on loans in cap law change - VIDEO

Desired effect

A year on, President Uhuru Kenyatta — whose signature brought the law into effect — reversed the conviction he shared with the legislature, conceding that the amendment did not have the desired effect.

The adverse effects of caps on small borrowers come as no surprise. It is a globally documented phenomenon.

This reversal must leave the public questioning the insights that drove the decision to implement an interest rate cap, the advisers that proposed it and the depth of considerations made by the executive before signing it into law.

Banks play an important intermediary role in the economy by connecting those who have cash and are in want of investment opportunities to those who are or could be engaged in productive economic activities but do not have the financial wherewithal.

The banks ‘buy’ deposits and ‘sell’ loans, earning the difference. Those deposits and loans are bought and sold at an ‘interest rate’.

Additionally, the buyers of those loans are businesses and the government.

The government is a less risky borrower than the small businesses and also has the capacity to be a bigger player in the loan market than several businesses put together.

If the government and many small businesses competed for loans at the same interest rates, banks will prefer to lend to the government.

Tracking borrowers

Because banks spend a lot of time and money vetting and tracking borrowers, they will prefer to lend to the government even if both the small businesses and the government were paying the same interest rates.

As the cap came into force, the government gave the verbal signal that it would stay away from the domestic credit market and then did the opposite by increasing its domestic borrowing.

The effect was that the interest rate cap made it difficult for the SMEs, in whose name the law was enacted, ...
Read More

Category: business news lifestyle corporate markets economy opinion

Suggested

11 hours ago, 00:07
@StandardMedia - By: Lee Mwiti
State offers to make refunds on housing tax

CS assures those who do not qualify for houses under proposed State plan that they will get back their contributions. ...

Category: business news
1 hours ago, 10:23
@BusinessDaily - By: Galgallo Fayo
Embattled UNEP head refunds travel expenses

The Unep boss makes clear his intention to stay put, insisting that he will accept personal responsibility . ...

Category: business news
1 hours ago, 10:12
@BusinessDaily - By: Galgallo Fayo
Karume estate in deeper trouble

KRA issued the Jacaranda Hotels Limited with an enforcement notice on January 12, seeking immediate payment of tax arrears amounting to Sh197 million. ...

Category: business news lifestyle markets
Now
@BusinessDaily - By: Victor Juma
Uhuru hits consumers with more hidden taxes

Tough times ahead as it emerges that President’s memo included an array of new and higher levies expected to significantly raise the cost of living. ...

Category: business news opinion lifestyle
11 hours ago, 00:07
@StandardMedia - By: Moses Omusolo
Vivo wraps up Engen deal for Sh20 billion

Pact will see firm take over rival’s outlets in eight countries, including Kenya. ...

Category: business news
17 hours ago, 18:15
@BusinessDaily - By: Brian Ngugi
Uhuru slaps M-Pesa with 66pc mobile cash tax rise

The cost of sending money through mobile services such as Safaricom’s M-Pesa will increase further after President Uhuru Kenyatta proposed to raise tax on the services from 12 per cent to 20 per ...

Category: business news
Our App