@StandardMedia

Stand-off over DPP's appointment of Queens Counsel to lead case against Mwilu

1 weeks ago, 00:08

By: Paul Ogemba

[George Njunge, Standard]

The decision by the State to introduce a Queen’s Counsel to lead the case against Deputy Chief Justice Philomena Mwilu prompted a stand-off that paralysed the hearing.

Whereas Justice Mwilu’s lawyers insisted that Khawar Qureshi QC had no valid practising certificate and could not be allowed to address the court, the Director of Public Prosecutions’ team insisted it would not proceed without him.

And as a pointer to the hard-line positions that have surrounded the matter, the prosecution, too, insisted it would push for the disqualification of two senators who are representing Mwilu, citing conflict of interest as they sat in a Senate committee that received privileged information on the case. 

What started as a simple introduction of Prof Qureshi before the court turned out to be a dead end as he eventually left without showcasing his ability to prosecute the case.

The tough exchanges and hard-line stance taken by both sides continued to unveil the intrigues surrounding the case against the DCJ from the first day DPP Noordin Haji sought permission of Chief Justice David Maraga to arrest and prosecute Justice Mwilu.

Before answering the corruption charges, she filed a petition at the High Court, claiming the accusations were illegal since they were framed ostensibly to remove her from office over the decision to nullify the results of the August 8, 2017, presidential election.

For over one hour, Qureshi was treated to a show of the grit and agility of Mwilu’s lawyers, who opposed his presence, sparking the stand-off and counter-accusations from the DPP’s team, who also applied to have two senators ejected from the case.

Led by senior counsels James Orengo, Okong'o Omogeni and John Khaminwa, the DCJ’s team argued that even Kenyan lawyers were not allowed to practise if they did not have a valid licence, in accordance with the Advocates Act.

“What is good for the goose is also good for the gander; they don’t make it easy for us when we appear before their courts in Britain and we must also make it difficult for him to appear in our courts when he has no valid certificates,” said Mr Orengo.

He told the court that even the former solicitor general was sent packing by a British court when he appeared to argue a case on behalf of the Kenyan Government for lack of a practising licence and that it should not be made easy for Qureshi.

Orengo submitted that the DPP could not appoint Qureshi to lead the case under the Criminal Procedure Code and also allow him to lead the constitutional petition in which Justice Mwilu is challenging her prosecution.

“The law allows the DPP to appoint a special prosecutor in a criminal case, but to the extent that the Gazette notice refers to this petition then it is a nullity. Prof Qureshi cannot participate in these proceedings until the DPP puts his house in order,” said Orengo.

His submission jolted State prosecutors Dorcas Oduor and Alexander Muteti, who stood ...
Read More


Category: topnews news

Suggested

1 hours ago, 22:45
@TheStar - By: Imende Benjamin @ ...
Uhuru postpones dowry ceremony

President Uhuru Kenyatta has postponed paying the dowry of his great-grandmother named Musana from Narok after three centuries.The president wanted to pay the bride price to correct the wrongs his gre ...

Category: topnews news
1 hours ago, 22:45
@TheStar - By: Imende [email pro ...
Police on the lookout for daytime drunken drivers

Police have introduced daytime alcoblow tests to curb road carnage during the festive season.Inspector of General Joseph Boinnet on Friday said the alcoblow will remain in place even after the festive ...

Category: topnews news
3 hours ago, 21:13
@DailyNation - By: Ouma Wanzala
KCSE results out soon as marking ends, analysis begins

Examiner says the results are likely to be issued before December 20. ...

Category: topnews news
3 hours ago, 21:13
@CITIZENTV - By: Sam Gituku
Kagame to Burundi: Leave us out of your problems

Rwandan President Paul Kagame has distanced his Government from accusations that it had a role to play in the absence of Burundi at an EAC summit ...

Category: topnews news
3 hours ago, 21:33
@TheStar - By: Kiplang'at Kirui ...
Maasai elders deny opposing new currency coins

Maasai Council of elders have denied claims being circulated in the social media that they have opposed new currency coins launched by President Uhuru Kenyatta on Tuesday.National organising secretary ...

Category: topnews news
3 hours ago, 20:42
@TheStar - By: Maurice Alal @ala ...
Four fishermen drown after boat capsizes in Lake Victoria

Four fishermen drowned on Thursday after their boat capsized in Lake Victoria at Seme, Kisumu county. They are Dennis Abala, Kennedy Oketch, Wilson Ndolo, and Chrispinus Bolo from West Kadinga sub-loc ...

Category: topnews news

@StandardMedia

Stand-off over DPP's appointment of Queens Counsel to lead case against Mwilu

1 weeks ago, 00:08

By: Paul Ogemba

[George Njunge, Standard]

The decision by the State to introduce a Queen’s Counsel to lead the case against Deputy Chief Justice Philomena Mwilu prompted a stand-off that paralysed the hearing.

Whereas Justice Mwilu’s lawyers insisted that Khawar Qureshi QC had no valid practising certificate and could not be allowed to address the court, the Director of Public Prosecutions’ team insisted it would not proceed without him.

And as a pointer to the hard-line positions that have surrounded the matter, the prosecution, too, insisted it would push for the disqualification of two senators who are representing Mwilu, citing conflict of interest as they sat in a Senate committee that received privileged information on the case. 

What started as a simple introduction of Prof Qureshi before the court turned out to be a dead end as he eventually left without showcasing his ability to prosecute the case.

The tough exchanges and hard-line stance taken by both sides continued to unveil the intrigues surrounding the case against the DCJ from the first day DPP Noordin Haji sought permission of Chief Justice David Maraga to arrest and prosecute Justice Mwilu.

Before answering the corruption charges, she filed a petition at the High Court, claiming the accusations were illegal since they were framed ostensibly to remove her from office over the decision to nullify the results of the August 8, 2017, presidential election.

For over one hour, Qureshi was treated to a show of the grit and agility of Mwilu’s lawyers, who opposed his presence, sparking the stand-off and counter-accusations from the DPP’s team, who also applied to have two senators ejected from the case.

Led by senior counsels James Orengo, Okong'o Omogeni and John Khaminwa, the DCJ’s team argued that even Kenyan lawyers were not allowed to practise if they did not have a valid licence, in accordance with the Advocates Act.

“What is good for the goose is also good for the gander; they don’t make it easy for us when we appear before their courts in Britain and we must also make it difficult for him to appear in our courts when he has no valid certificates,” said Mr Orengo.

He told the court that even the former solicitor general was sent packing by a British court when he appeared to argue a case on behalf of the Kenyan Government for lack of a practising licence and that it should not be made easy for Qureshi.

Orengo submitted that the DPP could not appoint Qureshi to lead the case under the Criminal Procedure Code and also allow him to lead the constitutional petition in which Justice Mwilu is challenging her prosecution.

“The law allows the DPP to appoint a special prosecutor in a criminal case, but to the extent that the Gazette notice refers to this petition then it is a nullity. Prof Qureshi cannot participate in these proceedings until the DPP puts his house in order,” said Orengo.

His submission jolted State prosecutors Dorcas Oduor and Alexander Muteti, who stood ...
Read More

Category: topnews news

Suggested

1 hours ago, 22:45
@TheStar - By: Imende Benjamin @ ...
Uhuru postpones dowry ceremony

President Uhuru Kenyatta has postponed paying the dowry of his great-grandmother named Musana from Narok after three centuries.The president wanted to pay the bride price to correct the wrongs his gre ...

Category: topnews news
1 hours ago, 22:45
@TheStar - By: Imende [email pro ...
Police on the lookout for daytime drunken drivers

Police have introduced daytime alcoblow tests to curb road carnage during the festive season.Inspector of General Joseph Boinnet on Friday said the alcoblow will remain in place even after the festive ...

Category: topnews news
3 hours ago, 21:13
@DailyNation - By: Ouma Wanzala
KCSE results out soon as marking ends, analysis begins

Examiner says the results are likely to be issued before December 20. ...

Category: topnews news
3 hours ago, 21:13
@CITIZENTV - By: Sam Gituku
Kagame to Burundi: Leave us out of your problems

Rwandan President Paul Kagame has distanced his Government from accusations that it had a role to play in the absence of Burundi at an EAC summit ...

Category: topnews news
3 hours ago, 21:33
@TheStar - By: Kiplang'at Kirui ...
Maasai elders deny opposing new currency coins

Maasai Council of elders have denied claims being circulated in the social media that they have opposed new currency coins launched by President Uhuru Kenyatta on Tuesday.National organising secretary ...

Category: topnews news
3 hours ago, 20:42
@TheStar - By: Maurice Alal @ala ...
Four fishermen drown after boat capsizes in Lake Victoria

Four fishermen drowned on Thursday after their boat capsized in Lake Victoria at Seme, Kisumu county. They are Dennis Abala, Kennedy Oketch, Wilson Ndolo, and Chrispinus Bolo from West Kadinga sub-loc ...

Category: topnews news
Our App