@TheEastAfrican

Reforms and strategy will help lawyers litigate against large scale government violence

5 months ago, 16 Maý 16:37

By: Sylvie Namwase

In a recent decision by the East African Court of Justice, the East African Law Society lost a petition against the Attorney General of Uganda based on failure to adduce sufficient evidence.

The Law Society brought the petition on behalf of aggrieved Ugandans alleging that Ugandan state security agencies had used excessive force to disperse a series of lawful assemblies in 2011, in what famously came to be dubbed “walk to work protests.”

The protests were against the rising fuel prices and cost of living in Uganda.

The alleged unlawful use of force resulted in the death of about 10 people including two children, unlawful detentions, destruction of property, grave injuries among other violations of the Ugandan Constitution, the African Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights and the Treaty establishing the East African Community.

The evidence, which the petitioners produced to support these claims, consisted of sworn affidavits, a DVD and newspaper clippings. The petitioners did not however produce certain key witnesses for oral testimony and cross-examination.

As part of their main claims, the petitioners maintained that the listed violations had been widely reported in print and electronic media all over the world, and had become so notorious that every person had to have had notice of them.

The Court did not agree. It further noted that given the gravity of the nature of allegations against the respondents, it was only prudent that it only accept evidence that could be verified. Drawing upon various standards evidentiary of the International Criminal Courts, Criminal Tribunals and the European Court on Human Rights, the Court rejected the DVD as inadmissible in evidence.

Finding the petitioners’ evidence weak overall, the court dismissed the petition.

Standard of proof

The loss of this petition on grounds of inadequate evidence demonstrates a major challenge of pursuing domestic justice for victims of large-scale violence by non-democratic states in Africa.

Initiatives taken towards public interest human rights litigation on behalf of victims would offer a suitable way to fill this impunity gap. The standard of proof hereunder is on a balance of probabilities and the victims have more agency and control over their case against the state than they would if public prosecution was their only option.

Unfortunately, the decision also highlights that even though a lower evidentiary burden exists for human rights cases, it is still relatively complex to meet for large-scale human rights violations by state agencies.

It would require litigants to prove multiple violations through identifying and producing many victims as witnesses, gathering and securing forensic and other evidence, all while ensuring witness protection and co-operation from relevant state agencies.

These challenges are arguably similar to those experienced by prosecutors in prominent international courts and tribunals, yet there are no identifiable institutional frameworks or initiatives within the legal fraternity in East Africa and the wider African Continent to offer specific training skills, human resources and funds to match the nature of these challenges.

Lawyers pursuing these cases would likely benefit from strategic approaches on common issues such as ...
Read More


Category: topnews news oped opinion

Suggested

1 hours ago, 06:31
@DailyNation - By: Daily Monitor
Ugandan woman killed in Jordan, kidneys removed

The woman, 32, was lured to Jordan where her kidneys were removed. ...

Category: topnews news
1 hour ago
@TheStar - By: Star Reporter
Strange man in Maribe's cell, Uhuru to tame MCAs trips, Storm at DCI: Your Breakfast Briefing

Good Morning.Auditor General Edward Ouko has raised alarm over the possible loss of Sh2.1 billion fertiliser subsidy funds at the National Cereals and Produce Board.The subsidy fund is part of the Sh3 ...

Category: topnews news
1 hour ago
@TheStar - By: Oliver Mathenge @ ...
Stranger quizzed me in Gigiri police cell – Maribe

A stranger tried to interrogate Citizen TV journalist and murder suspect Jacque Maribe while she was held at the Gigiri police station, she has told the court.The man who was booked in as a suspect wo ...

Category: topnews news
1 hour ago
@TheStar - By: Otiende Amollo
EXPERT COMMENT: Devolution CS cannot control County Assembly expenditure

The legitimacy of the directive that MCAs get clearance from the Ministry of Devolution before a foreign trip is questionable. However, the rationale is understandable. The legitimacy is questionable ...

Category: topnews news
1 hours ago, 06:31
@TheStar - By: Samuel Kisika And ...
Anger as Uhuru seeks to tame MCAs' foreign trips

President Uhuru Kenyatta’s administration wants to save up to Sh30 billion by restricting foreign travel for county government staff and MCAs in austerity measures aimed at cutting government expendit ...

Category: topnews news
2 hours ago, 05:16
@AfricaNews - By: Daniel Mumbere
Photos: Ugandans celebrate iconic cable-stay bridge over River Nile | Africanews

The Source of the Nile Bridge, commissioned on Wednesday, is expected to enhance economic and regional integration with neighbouring countries like Kenya, provide safer travel and enhance tourism. ...

Category: africa topnews news

@TheEastAfrican

Reforms and strategy will help lawyers litigate against large scale government violence

5 months ago, 16 Maý 16:37

By: Sylvie Namwase

In a recent decision by the East African Court of Justice, the East African Law Society lost a petition against the Attorney General of Uganda based on failure to adduce sufficient evidence.

The Law Society brought the petition on behalf of aggrieved Ugandans alleging that Ugandan state security agencies had used excessive force to disperse a series of lawful assemblies in 2011, in what famously came to be dubbed “walk to work protests.”

The protests were against the rising fuel prices and cost of living in Uganda.

The alleged unlawful use of force resulted in the death of about 10 people including two children, unlawful detentions, destruction of property, grave injuries among other violations of the Ugandan Constitution, the African Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights and the Treaty establishing the East African Community.

The evidence, which the petitioners produced to support these claims, consisted of sworn affidavits, a DVD and newspaper clippings. The petitioners did not however produce certain key witnesses for oral testimony and cross-examination.

As part of their main claims, the petitioners maintained that the listed violations had been widely reported in print and electronic media all over the world, and had become so notorious that every person had to have had notice of them.

The Court did not agree. It further noted that given the gravity of the nature of allegations against the respondents, it was only prudent that it only accept evidence that could be verified. Drawing upon various standards evidentiary of the International Criminal Courts, Criminal Tribunals and the European Court on Human Rights, the Court rejected the DVD as inadmissible in evidence.

Finding the petitioners’ evidence weak overall, the court dismissed the petition.

Standard of proof

The loss of this petition on grounds of inadequate evidence demonstrates a major challenge of pursuing domestic justice for victims of large-scale violence by non-democratic states in Africa.

Initiatives taken towards public interest human rights litigation on behalf of victims would offer a suitable way to fill this impunity gap. The standard of proof hereunder is on a balance of probabilities and the victims have more agency and control over their case against the state than they would if public prosecution was their only option.

Unfortunately, the decision also highlights that even though a lower evidentiary burden exists for human rights cases, it is still relatively complex to meet for large-scale human rights violations by state agencies.

It would require litigants to prove multiple violations through identifying and producing many victims as witnesses, gathering and securing forensic and other evidence, all while ensuring witness protection and co-operation from relevant state agencies.

These challenges are arguably similar to those experienced by prosecutors in prominent international courts and tribunals, yet there are no identifiable institutional frameworks or initiatives within the legal fraternity in East Africa and the wider African Continent to offer specific training skills, human resources and funds to match the nature of these challenges.

Lawyers pursuing these cases would likely benefit from strategic approaches on common issues such as ...
Read More

Category: topnews news oped opinion

Suggested

1 hours ago, 06:31
@DailyNation - By: Daily Monitor
Ugandan woman killed in Jordan, kidneys removed

The woman, 32, was lured to Jordan where her kidneys were removed. ...

Category: topnews news
1 hour ago
@TheStar - By: Star Reporter
Strange man in Maribe's cell, Uhuru to tame MCAs trips, Storm at DCI: Your Breakfast Briefing

Good Morning.Auditor General Edward Ouko has raised alarm over the possible loss of Sh2.1 billion fertiliser subsidy funds at the National Cereals and Produce Board.The subsidy fund is part of the Sh3 ...

Category: topnews news
1 hour ago
@TheStar - By: Oliver Mathenge @ ...
Stranger quizzed me in Gigiri police cell – Maribe

A stranger tried to interrogate Citizen TV journalist and murder suspect Jacque Maribe while she was held at the Gigiri police station, she has told the court.The man who was booked in as a suspect wo ...

Category: topnews news
1 hour ago
@TheStar - By: Otiende Amollo
EXPERT COMMENT: Devolution CS cannot control County Assembly expenditure

The legitimacy of the directive that MCAs get clearance from the Ministry of Devolution before a foreign trip is questionable. However, the rationale is understandable. The legitimacy is questionable ...

Category: topnews news
1 hours ago, 06:31
@TheStar - By: Samuel Kisika And ...
Anger as Uhuru seeks to tame MCAs' foreign trips

President Uhuru Kenyatta’s administration wants to save up to Sh30 billion by restricting foreign travel for county government staff and MCAs in austerity measures aimed at cutting government expendit ...

Category: topnews news
2 hours ago, 05:16
@AfricaNews - By: Daniel Mumbere
Photos: Ugandans celebrate iconic cable-stay bridge over River Nile | Africanews

The Source of the Nile Bridge, commissioned on Wednesday, is expected to enhance economic and regional integration with neighbouring countries like Kenya, provide safer travel and enhance tourism. ...

Category: africa topnews news
Our App