@TheStar

MUGA: Water wars and hydropolitics

2 months ago, 10 Oct 22:42

By: Wycliffe Muga @mu ...

It was a phrase first used by the celebrated Egyptian intellectual, Ismail Serageldin. And though thus far there has been no sign of the loudly proclaimed “water wars”, this phrase does shine a light on the fact that the universal need for fresh water, has a unique tendency to escalate political tensions.

As an Egyptian, Serageldin was uniquely well-placed to appreciate these tensions, as his country is totally dependent on water from the Nile River — a river that has its sources in several nations both near and far, any of which nations might have its own ideas of how the waters of the Nile should be used or shared.

Kenya also faces a somewhat similar dilemma to that of Egypt — albeit on a very much smaller scale. The principal source of the waters that flow into our Lake Turkana is the Omo River – that, unfortunately for us, is not in Kenya, but in Ethiopia.

And as it happens, Kenya has signed a memorandum of understanding with Ethiopia to buy about one-third of the power produced by a hydroelectric dam on this river. But at the same time, the negative environmental impacts expected to arise from this project, will mostly be felt in Kenya, with some environmentalists sensationally claiming that the Gibe-III Dam on the Omo River “will kill Lake Turkana”.

So “water politics” as some term it, is a very complex matter indeed. Far more complex than the good people of Murang’a seem to appreciate, when – according to recent reports – they “overwhelmingly” support their governor, Mwangi wa Iria, in his demand that Murang’a be allowed to impose a tax on all water supplied to Nairobi from his county.

The Murang’a governor is playing on a longstanding staple of Kenyan political psychology: That the public is always delighted to hear that there is some valuable resource in their backyard, which has been unfairly taken advantage of by “outsiders”. And that, at the very least, they deserve massive compensation if indeed they are to permit the exploiting of this resource by the said “outsiders” (in this case the residents of Nairobi, and the central government).

Indeed, it was opposition leader Raila Odinga, who first condemned the Murang’a-based Northern Water Collection Tunnel project, as a catastrophe in the making, going so far as to declare that this perfectly rational World Bank-funded project was "one of the most disastrous initiatives as it will turn Murang’a, Garissa, Ukambani and Tana River Delta regions into deserts, within five years of completion".

This declaration must have proved appealing to many in Murang’a, even though it did not translate into pro-Raila votes. So, the governor has now adopted the idea as his own, only modifying it to focus on a demand for compensation, instead of condemning it wholesale.

This is a far shrewder proposition, as it asks for something that can be negotiated and settled. There was never any question of the project being stopped altogether, however, strongly the people of Murang’a may have felt about it.

But the governor’s ...
Read More


Category: topnews news oped opinion

Suggested

1 hour ago
@DailyNation -
Solskjaer set for United interim role after website gaffe

There has been no official announcement from the club. ...

Category: topnews news
1 hours ago, 06:45
@CITIZENTV - By: Cnn
EU court tells Poland to ‘immediately suspend’ law forcing judges into retirement

The European Union's highest court ruled on Monday that Poland must "immediately suspend" a law that forces Supreme Court judges over age 65 to retire. ...

Category: topnews news
1 hours ago, 06:12
@CITIZENTV - By: Cnn
Japan to have first aircraft carriers since World War II

Japan is poised to put its first aircraft carriers to sea since World War II, refitting its Izumo-class warships to carry US-designed F-35B fighter jets. ...

Category: topnews news
2 hours ago, 05:51
@DailyNation - By: Afp
Mourinho's fall from grace at United in quotes

The 55-year-old's unhappiness at the club manifested itself even before the season started. ...

Category: topnews news
1 hours ago, 06:23
@TheStar - By: James Mbaka And K ...
Matiang’i goes to war with DP Ruto

A vicious fight between Deputy President William Ruto and Interior Cabinet Secretary Fred Matiang'i yesterday exploded into the open.The two have been engaged in serious fighting, which has been kept ...

Category: topnews news
1 hours ago, 06:23
@TheStar - By: Star Reporter
Matiang'i fights Ruto, Christmas in the cold, Grabbed JKIA land: Your Breakfast Briefing

Good MorningA vicious fight between Deputy President William Ruto and Interior Cabinet Secretary Fred Matiang'i on Tuesday exploded into the open.The two have been engaged in serious fighting, which h ...

Category: topnews news

@TheStar

MUGA: Water wars and hydropolitics

2 months ago, 10 Oct 22:42

By: Wycliffe Muga @mu ...

It was a phrase first used by the celebrated Egyptian intellectual, Ismail Serageldin. And though thus far there has been no sign of the loudly proclaimed “water wars”, this phrase does shine a light on the fact that the universal need for fresh water, has a unique tendency to escalate political tensions.

As an Egyptian, Serageldin was uniquely well-placed to appreciate these tensions, as his country is totally dependent on water from the Nile River — a river that has its sources in several nations both near and far, any of which nations might have its own ideas of how the waters of the Nile should be used or shared.

Kenya also faces a somewhat similar dilemma to that of Egypt — albeit on a very much smaller scale. The principal source of the waters that flow into our Lake Turkana is the Omo River – that, unfortunately for us, is not in Kenya, but in Ethiopia.

And as it happens, Kenya has signed a memorandum of understanding with Ethiopia to buy about one-third of the power produced by a hydroelectric dam on this river. But at the same time, the negative environmental impacts expected to arise from this project, will mostly be felt in Kenya, with some environmentalists sensationally claiming that the Gibe-III Dam on the Omo River “will kill Lake Turkana”.

So “water politics” as some term it, is a very complex matter indeed. Far more complex than the good people of Murang’a seem to appreciate, when – according to recent reports – they “overwhelmingly” support their governor, Mwangi wa Iria, in his demand that Murang’a be allowed to impose a tax on all water supplied to Nairobi from his county.

The Murang’a governor is playing on a longstanding staple of Kenyan political psychology: That the public is always delighted to hear that there is some valuable resource in their backyard, which has been unfairly taken advantage of by “outsiders”. And that, at the very least, they deserve massive compensation if indeed they are to permit the exploiting of this resource by the said “outsiders” (in this case the residents of Nairobi, and the central government).

Indeed, it was opposition leader Raila Odinga, who first condemned the Murang’a-based Northern Water Collection Tunnel project, as a catastrophe in the making, going so far as to declare that this perfectly rational World Bank-funded project was "one of the most disastrous initiatives as it will turn Murang’a, Garissa, Ukambani and Tana River Delta regions into deserts, within five years of completion".

This declaration must have proved appealing to many in Murang’a, even though it did not translate into pro-Raila votes. So, the governor has now adopted the idea as his own, only modifying it to focus on a demand for compensation, instead of condemning it wholesale.

This is a far shrewder proposition, as it asks for something that can be negotiated and settled. There was never any question of the project being stopped altogether, however, strongly the people of Murang’a may have felt about it.

But the governor’s ...
Read More

Category: topnews news oped opinion

Suggested

1 hour ago
@DailyNation -
Solskjaer set for United interim role after website gaffe

There has been no official announcement from the club. ...

Category: topnews news
1 hours ago, 06:45
@CITIZENTV - By: Cnn
EU court tells Poland to ‘immediately suspend’ law forcing judges into retirement

The European Union's highest court ruled on Monday that Poland must "immediately suspend" a law that forces Supreme Court judges over age 65 to retire. ...

Category: topnews news
1 hours ago, 06:12
@CITIZENTV - By: Cnn
Japan to have first aircraft carriers since World War II

Japan is poised to put its first aircraft carriers to sea since World War II, refitting its Izumo-class warships to carry US-designed F-35B fighter jets. ...

Category: topnews news
2 hours ago, 05:51
@DailyNation - By: Afp
Mourinho's fall from grace at United in quotes

The 55-year-old's unhappiness at the club manifested itself even before the season started. ...

Category: topnews news
1 hours ago, 06:23
@TheStar - By: James Mbaka And K ...
Matiang’i goes to war with DP Ruto

A vicious fight between Deputy President William Ruto and Interior Cabinet Secretary Fred Matiang'i yesterday exploded into the open.The two have been engaged in serious fighting, which has been kept ...

Category: topnews news
1 hours ago, 06:23
@TheStar - By: Star Reporter
Matiang'i fights Ruto, Christmas in the cold, Grabbed JKIA land: Your Breakfast Briefing

Good MorningA vicious fight between Deputy President William Ruto and Interior Cabinet Secretary Fred Matiang'i on Tuesday exploded into the open.The two have been engaged in serious fighting, which h ...

Category: topnews news
Our App