@BusinessDaily

LUMUMBA: Monsanto not entirely honest about GMOs

3 months ago, 14 Mar 10:47

By: Stephen Lumumba

American biotechnology giant, Monsanto, has recently renewed its quest to popularise genetically modified organisms (GMOs) as Kenya and Africa’s best bet against hunger. In an interview published in the Business Daily two weeks ago, Monsanto’s vice-president for global commercial and supply chain - Jesus Madrazo - said GMO crops provided Africa with the right technology and opportunity to respond to challenges like climate change and impact on food production. Our observation is that Mr Madrazo did not fully explore the multiple reasons for the declining output but instead chose to blame it largely on climate change – for which GMOs are constantly prescribed as the solution. Nothing could be further from the truth. No consensus Like many countries around the world, Kenya’s reluctance to approve environmental release of GMO crops points to the fact that there is no consensus among stakeholders that genetic modification is the panacea to food insecurity. Indeed, the possible adverse effects of GMOs on human health have not been empirically scrutinised by organisations such as Monsanto to allay food safety concerns related to this technology. It cannot be argued that the government of Kenya is making a mistake in protecting its citizens from eating potentially harmful foods when healthy alternatives abound. More importantly, it is worth noting that Monsanto owns more than 80 per cent of all GMO germplasm in the world and finances the bulk of GM research (with obvious partiality in terms of research design) and, therefore, has a direct and overriding interest in GM adoption in Kenya. This should not be overlooked by policy makers at the expense of public health. Mr Madrazo’s responses to certain questions during the interview were particularly disconcerting. For instance, when asked about Monsanto’s relevance in the emerging dispensation where climate change is posing a major challenge to food security, his answer was simply the adaptation of biotechnology. Never mind that climate change is only one variable in our food production matrix. In our experience, the main reasons for declining output is declining soil fertility due to misuse of chemical fertilizers and pesticides, application of sub-standard chemical fertilizers and pesticides, causing high acidity in our soils (all owing to lack of farm-level technical advice) and over-reliance on rain-fed farming. There’s need for revival of extension service, and intensification of post-product registration surveillance by the Pest Control Products Board (PCPB) to ensure consistency in the efficacy and public health profile of pest control products. Misuse of fertiliser, pesticides It is our position as Kenya Pyrethrum Joint Venture, that intensified food production, by itself, may not yield the desired results if regulations governing food safety, from farm-to-fork, are not reviewed to enhance public health and environmental conservation through adoption of pyrethrum-based natural, organic pesticides, which are proven to be healthy safer to humans and the environment and have greater knock-down effect on pests, compared to synthetics. The food we produce is increasingly becoming unsafe owing to high acidity in our soils and this is a problem we see consistently across ...
Read More


Category: business corporate news opinion lifestyle economy markets

Suggested

9 hours ago, 00:00
@CITIZENTV - By: Reuters
MP Njomo says “pretty sure” move to repeal rate cap will be defeated

MP Njomo says "pretty sure" move to repeal rate cap will be defeated ...

Category: business
3 hours ago, 06:22
@AfricaNews - By: Africanews
Ethiopia appoints new central bank governor | Africanews

The government announced earlier this month that it will sell stakes in its telecoms monopoly, state-owned carrier Ethiopian Airlines and other assets, a decision that could open one of the world’s ...

Category: africa africa_business business news
7 hours ago, 02:04
@TheStar - By: Abel Muhatia @muh ...
Stanbic lists in Singapore trade finance platform

Stanbic Bank has joined a list of more than 40 financial institutions across 17 countries to list in a digital trade finance platform with an aim to distribute trade assets. The bank has signed a memo ...

Category: business news
8 hours ago, 01:34
@TheStar - By: Brian Wasuna @bwa ...
KFC, contractor fry each other after building deal turns sour

KFC is embroiled in a vicious fight with a contractor that it hired to build five of its branches in Nairobi, Nakuru and Nanyuki.Gemineye Construction argues that KFC underpaid it by Sh34 million for ...

Category: topnews news business
16 hours ago, 17:53
@BusinessDaily - By: Bd Reporter
Equity Bank bags Chinese company loans deal

Equity Group has signed a two-year deal with China National Aero-technology International Engineering Corporation (AVIC-ENG) that opens a credit line for the Chinese firm in East Africa. ...

Category: business opinion news lifestyle corporate economy
6 hours ago, 03:00
@BusinessDaily - By: Annie Njanja
Telcom operators reject money tax

Kenya’s telecoms operators have expressed disappointment at Treasury’s intention to increase excise tax on mobile money transactions. ...

Category: business lifestyle news

@BusinessDaily

LUMUMBA: Monsanto not entirely honest about GMOs

3 months ago, 14 Mar 10:47

By: Stephen Lumumba
American biotechnology giant, Monsanto, has recently renewed its quest to popularise genetically modified organisms (GMOs) as Kenya and Africa’s best bet against hunger. In an interview published in the Business Daily two weeks ago, Monsanto’s vice-president for global commercial and supply chain - Jesus Madrazo - said GMO crops provided Africa with the right technology and opportunity to respond to challenges like climate change and impact on food production. Our observation is that Mr Madrazo did not fully explore the multiple reasons for the declining output but instead chose to blame it largely on climate change – for which GMOs are constantly prescribed as the solution. Nothing could be further from the truth. No consensus Like many countries around the world, Kenya’s reluctance to approve environmental release of GMO crops points to the fact that there is no consensus among stakeholders that genetic modification is the panacea to food insecurity. Indeed, the possible adverse effects of GMOs on human health have not been empirically scrutinised by organisations such as Monsanto to allay food safety concerns related to this technology. It cannot be argued that the government of Kenya is making a mistake in protecting its citizens from eating potentially harmful foods when healthy alternatives abound. More importantly, it is worth noting that Monsanto owns more than 80 per cent of all GMO germplasm in the world and finances the bulk of GM research (with obvious partiality in terms of research design) and, therefore, has a direct and overriding interest in GM adoption in Kenya. This should not be overlooked by policy makers at the expense of public health. Mr Madrazo’s responses to certain questions during the interview were particularly disconcerting. For instance, when asked about Monsanto’s relevance in the emerging dispensation where climate change is posing a major challenge to food security, his answer was simply the adaptation of biotechnology. Never mind that climate change is only one variable in our food production matrix. In our experience, the main reasons for declining output is declining soil fertility due to misuse of chemical fertilizers and pesticides, application of sub-standard chemical fertilizers and pesticides, causing high acidity in our soils (all owing to lack of farm-level technical advice) and over-reliance on rain-fed farming. There’s need for revival of extension service, and intensification of post-product registration surveillance by the Pest Control Products Board (PCPB) to ensure consistency in the efficacy and public health profile of pest control products. Misuse of fertiliser, pesticides It is our position as Kenya Pyrethrum Joint Venture, that intensified food production, by itself, may not yield the desired results if regulations governing food safety, from farm-to-fork, are not reviewed to enhance public health and environmental conservation through adoption of pyrethrum-based natural, organic pesticides, which are proven to be healthy safer to humans and the environment and have greater knock-down effect on pests, compared to synthetics. The food we produce is increasingly becoming unsafe owing to high acidity in our soils and this is a problem we see consistently across ...
Read More

Category: business corporate news opinion lifestyle economy markets

Suggested

9 hours ago, 00:00
@CITIZENTV - By: Reuters
MP Njomo says “pretty sure” move to repeal rate cap will be defeated

MP Njomo says "pretty sure" move to repeal rate cap will be defeated ...

Category: business
3 hours ago, 06:22
@AfricaNews - By: Africanews
Ethiopia appoints new central bank governor | Africanews

The government announced earlier this month that it will sell stakes in its telecoms monopoly, state-owned carrier Ethiopian Airlines and other assets, a decision that could open one of the world’s ...

Category: africa africa_business business news
7 hours ago, 02:04
@TheStar - By: Abel Muhatia @muh ...
Stanbic lists in Singapore trade finance platform

Stanbic Bank has joined a list of more than 40 financial institutions across 17 countries to list in a digital trade finance platform with an aim to distribute trade assets. The bank has signed a memo ...

Category: business news
8 hours ago, 01:34
@TheStar - By: Brian Wasuna @bwa ...
KFC, contractor fry each other after building deal turns sour

KFC is embroiled in a vicious fight with a contractor that it hired to build five of its branches in Nairobi, Nakuru and Nanyuki.Gemineye Construction argues that KFC underpaid it by Sh34 million for ...

Category: topnews news business
16 hours ago, 17:53
@BusinessDaily - By: Bd Reporter
Equity Bank bags Chinese company loans deal

Equity Group has signed a two-year deal with China National Aero-technology International Engineering Corporation (AVIC-ENG) that opens a credit line for the Chinese firm in East Africa. ...

Category: business opinion news lifestyle corporate economy
6 hours ago, 03:00
@BusinessDaily - By: Annie Njanja
Telcom operators reject money tax

Kenya’s telecoms operators have expressed disappointment at Treasury’s intention to increase excise tax on mobile money transactions. ...

Category: business lifestyle news
Our App