@DailyNation

Judges were out to nail us, Chiloba says on Supreme Court poll ruling

3 months ago, 14 Sep 00:01

By: Patrick Lang'at

On September 1, 2017, in a 4-2 majority decision, the Supreme Court annulled President Uhuru Kenyatta’s election, terming it “invalid, null and void” and sending shock waves across the country.

But for the Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission (IEBC), it has now emerged, their case had been lost even before the six-judge bench retreated to write their judgment on August 29 following a two-day marathon hearing.

“Based on our own observation, you had a feeling that something wrong was going to happen; from the questions the judges were asking, you got a sense that it was a lost cause,” IEBC chief executive Ezra Chiloba told the Nation in an interview.

Mr Chiloba spoke just a few days before the IEBC embarked on a post-election evaluation forum in Nairobi, which ended Thursday, and where the conduct of the annulled poll, and the repeat election in October, were analysed by experts, the civil society, and election observers.

RESULTS SCRUTINISED

In reflecting on the landmark ruling — the first in Africa, and only the fourth in the world — Mr Chiloba argues that right from the start the Supreme Court had gone out of their way to find fault with how they had conducted the election.

“When you are presiding over such a dispute, you must give the benefit of doubt to the institutions that people have set for themselves — and given delegated power — that they will do the right thing. In this case, we saw an approach of ‘IEBC has done something wrong, let us go and find out what,'" Mr Chiloba said.

Mr Chiloba also revisited the results of the scrutiny ordered by the Supreme Court, and which sampled 4,299 Forms 34As from five counties — an analysis Mr Chiloba told investigators in October last year were in ‘sharp contrast’ with what the commission had presented.

Out of those, the scrutiny showed that 481 of them were carbon copies but signed with another 157 not signed, 269 original copies not signed, with 26 other originals signed, and scanned.

VALIDATION OF REPORT

A total of 58 were photocopies of which 46 had not been signed, and 11 had no watermark security feature.

“We believe that the scrutiny of forms led by the registrar of the Supreme Court did not reflect the true nature of the forms as delivered to the court by the commission,” he said of the scrutiny that the petitioners termed as the smoking gun, and which played a huge part in the annulment of the poll.

Mr Chiloba was referring to the requirement in law for the commission to present to the court certified copies of all results declaration forms four days after the filing of a petition, and which he believes the court did not counter-check against what was said in the report.

“We were not given an opportunity to validate the report, or sign off on it when it was handed over to lawyers, who were given 10 minutes to argue on it before court.”

The veracity of the report on the scrutiny of the forms ...
Read More


Category: topnews news politics

Suggested

5 hours ago, 23:39
@CITIZENTV - By: Cnn
80 years on, Germany to pay compensation to Kindertransport survivors

The German government will make a one-off compensation payment to survivors of the Kindertransport program, which rescued Jewish children from Nazi Germany and brought them to Britain. ...

Category: topnews news
5 hours ago, 23:34
@DailyNation - By: Afp
Belgian Prime Minister Charles Michel announces resignation

Michel faced a possible no-confidence motion. ...

Category: topnews news
4 hours ago, 00:06
@DailyNation - By: Kennedy Kimanthi
CRA makes new proposals for funding counties

The proposed allocation formula will now be subjected to public participation before it goes to the Senate. ...

Category: topnews news
5 hours ago, 23:09
@CITIZENTV - By: Cnn
The business trends shaping Africa in 2019 — and beyond

The performance of some of Africa's largest economies in 2018 does not inspire confidence for the year ahead. ...

Category: topnews news
4 hours ago, 00:01
@TheStar - By: Corazon Wafula. @ ...
Victim’s kin blames trigger-happy cops

One of the six men killed during the Kolongolo clashes in Trans Nzoia only sought to know why police officers were beating his friend, his elder brother said yesterday.Duncan Walela said they will lea ...

Category: topnews news
6 hours ago, 22:39
@CITIZENTV - By: Reuters
Sri Lanka lawmakers defect from president to prime minister after dispute

Three lawmakers from Sri Lankan President Maithripala Sirisena’s party defected to the government of Prime Minister Ranil Wickremesinghe on Tuesday after a dispute between the two leaders. ...

Category: topnews news

@DailyNation

Judges were out to nail us, Chiloba says on Supreme Court poll ruling

3 months ago, 14 Sep 00:01

By: Patrick Lang'at

On September 1, 2017, in a 4-2 majority decision, the Supreme Court annulled President Uhuru Kenyatta’s election, terming it “invalid, null and void” and sending shock waves across the country.

But for the Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission (IEBC), it has now emerged, their case had been lost even before the six-judge bench retreated to write their judgment on August 29 following a two-day marathon hearing.

“Based on our own observation, you had a feeling that something wrong was going to happen; from the questions the judges were asking, you got a sense that it was a lost cause,” IEBC chief executive Ezra Chiloba told the Nation in an interview.

Mr Chiloba spoke just a few days before the IEBC embarked on a post-election evaluation forum in Nairobi, which ended Thursday, and where the conduct of the annulled poll, and the repeat election in October, were analysed by experts, the civil society, and election observers.

RESULTS SCRUTINISED

In reflecting on the landmark ruling — the first in Africa, and only the fourth in the world — Mr Chiloba argues that right from the start the Supreme Court had gone out of their way to find fault with how they had conducted the election.

“When you are presiding over such a dispute, you must give the benefit of doubt to the institutions that people have set for themselves — and given delegated power — that they will do the right thing. In this case, we saw an approach of ‘IEBC has done something wrong, let us go and find out what,'" Mr Chiloba said.

Mr Chiloba also revisited the results of the scrutiny ordered by the Supreme Court, and which sampled 4,299 Forms 34As from five counties — an analysis Mr Chiloba told investigators in October last year were in ‘sharp contrast’ with what the commission had presented.

Out of those, the scrutiny showed that 481 of them were carbon copies but signed with another 157 not signed, 269 original copies not signed, with 26 other originals signed, and scanned.

VALIDATION OF REPORT

A total of 58 were photocopies of which 46 had not been signed, and 11 had no watermark security feature.

“We believe that the scrutiny of forms led by the registrar of the Supreme Court did not reflect the true nature of the forms as delivered to the court by the commission,” he said of the scrutiny that the petitioners termed as the smoking gun, and which played a huge part in the annulment of the poll.

Mr Chiloba was referring to the requirement in law for the commission to present to the court certified copies of all results declaration forms four days after the filing of a petition, and which he believes the court did not counter-check against what was said in the report.

“We were not given an opportunity to validate the report, or sign off on it when it was handed over to lawyers, who were given 10 minutes to argue on it before court.”

The veracity of the report on the scrutiny of the forms ...
Read More

Category: topnews news politics

Suggested

5 hours ago, 23:39
@CITIZENTV - By: Cnn
80 years on, Germany to pay compensation to Kindertransport survivors

The German government will make a one-off compensation payment to survivors of the Kindertransport program, which rescued Jewish children from Nazi Germany and brought them to Britain. ...

Category: topnews news
5 hours ago, 23:34
@DailyNation - By: Afp
Belgian Prime Minister Charles Michel announces resignation

Michel faced a possible no-confidence motion. ...

Category: topnews news
4 hours ago, 00:06
@DailyNation - By: Kennedy Kimanthi
CRA makes new proposals for funding counties

The proposed allocation formula will now be subjected to public participation before it goes to the Senate. ...

Category: topnews news
5 hours ago, 23:09
@CITIZENTV - By: Cnn
The business trends shaping Africa in 2019 — and beyond

The performance of some of Africa's largest economies in 2018 does not inspire confidence for the year ahead. ...

Category: topnews news
4 hours ago, 00:01
@TheStar - By: Corazon Wafula. @ ...
Victim’s kin blames trigger-happy cops

One of the six men killed during the Kolongolo clashes in Trans Nzoia only sought to know why police officers were beating his friend, his elder brother said yesterday.Duncan Walela said they will lea ...

Category: topnews news
6 hours ago, 22:39
@CITIZENTV - By: Reuters
Sri Lanka lawmakers defect from president to prime minister after dispute

Three lawmakers from Sri Lankan President Maithripala Sirisena’s party defected to the government of Prime Minister Ranil Wickremesinghe on Tuesday after a dispute between the two leaders. ...

Category: topnews news
Our App