@DailyNation

Is the SGR a veritable success or an unsustainable extravaganza?

5 days ago, 00:09

By: Robert Shaw

The SGR is a part and parcel of the Kenyan fabric. Its passenger and cargo trains run like clockwork and the whole operation cruises along with impressive ease. Indeed, on the surface it looks like an example that much of Kenya could learn from.

Everything from its booking system to punctuality. It has proved increasingly popular and convenient for passengers and even attracted sceptics such as myself.

In theory, it all makes sense. We are the gateway for and the hub of East Africa and beyond. Several countries rely on us for imports and exports.

Our roads are clogged and continually worn down by heavy truckloads of cargo. Our old creaking railway from the days of East African Railways and Harbours is a struggling dinosaur for years of neglect and misuse.

It has been proved again and again over the centuries that a well-run railway can be the most economical and effective way to transport bulk cargo and, indeed, large volumes of passengers.

SEAMLESS TRANSPORT ROUTE

In comes SGR, which, in time, aims to become a seamless transport route to Uganda and beyond. But that is where the good news ends.

The SGR has been bedraggled in controversy. First, SGR1 from Miritini to Syokimau was notoriously expensive to build.

The project was not subjected to competitive tendering but cobbled together by a cabal of officials from Kenya and China.

The design, construction and operation were not segmented but fused — against standard professional norms. I suspect it contributed to the high cost.

I have no issue with the concept and vision, just the cost — one of the major causes of our surging debt.

A simple cost benefit analysis blurts out the question as to whether the gargantuan investment was worth it and could we not have built it for less?

CONTROVERSIES

Behind the semblance of a smoothly run operation lie several questions and controversies. Its day-to-day operation runs at a considerable loss.

It is important to be clear here: It’s running operation minus the debt repayment per se. Kenya Railways Managing Director Atanus Maina talks about operational viability in three to five years but that could be wishful thinking.

The bottom line is, its operational costs are abnormally high. There are 50 Chinese drivers alone and several hundreds of other Chinese manning the operation at every level and station, all paid by the revenue and subsidies.

If it wasn’t for the station names and the mix of passengers, one could be forgiven for thinking one were in mainland China!

The big and burning question is where to go from here because this project is heading into more controversy and massive debt that will become unsustainable. One controversy is its routing through parts of our precious but embattled Nairobi National Park.

INDEPENDENT BODY

The way forward does not lie with Kenya Railways or China Road and Bridge Corporation (CRBC) nor with any affiliate.

It lies with the government being bold enough ...
Read More


Category: topnews news oped opinion

Suggested

26 minutes
@DailyNation - By: Afp
Why Paris has renamed metro stations

The changes represent "winks" to the team, Paris transport operator RATP said Monday. ...

Category: topnews news sports
1 hour ago
@CITIZENTV - By: Benjamin Muriuki
Obama speaks on corruption in Kenya

Former US President Barack Obama on Monday commended Kenya for the progress that has been realised in the country since 1991 when he toured Kenya for the first time. ...

Category: topnews news
1 hours ago, 14:27
@DailyNation - By: Aggrey Mutambo
Barack Obama urges leaders to tackle graft

Former US President commends Uhuru and Raila for agreeing to work together. ...

Category: topnews news
1 hours ago, 14:29
@TheEastAfrican - By: Njiraini Muchira
Kenya banks ask court for respite over Treasury taxes

Minister can operationalise proposals in the Finance Act for up to 6 months without waiting for MPs to okay the Act. ...

Category: topnews news business
1 hours ago, 14:04
@StandardMedia - By: Silah Koskei
Attacking Raila and Uhuru might deny Ruto presidency, Keter warns

Keter faulted DP Ruto allies for ruining his presidential chances with constant accusations at Raila, Uhuru. ...

Category: topnews news
21 minutes
@TheStar - By: Brian Otieno @yob ...
NASA is dead but I'm not joining Ruto - Wetangula

NASA is dead but I will not join Deputy President William Ruto's camp, Bungoma senator Moses Wetangula has said.Wetang'ula said he has his own house (Ford Kenya) and will build it to make it stronger ...

Category: topnews news

@DailyNation

Is the SGR a veritable success or an unsustainable extravaganza?

5 days ago, 00:09

By: Robert Shaw

The SGR is a part and parcel of the Kenyan fabric. Its passenger and cargo trains run like clockwork and the whole operation cruises along with impressive ease. Indeed, on the surface it looks like an example that much of Kenya could learn from.

Everything from its booking system to punctuality. It has proved increasingly popular and convenient for passengers and even attracted sceptics such as myself.

In theory, it all makes sense. We are the gateway for and the hub of East Africa and beyond. Several countries rely on us for imports and exports.

Our roads are clogged and continually worn down by heavy truckloads of cargo. Our old creaking railway from the days of East African Railways and Harbours is a struggling dinosaur for years of neglect and misuse.

It has been proved again and again over the centuries that a well-run railway can be the most economical and effective way to transport bulk cargo and, indeed, large volumes of passengers.

SEAMLESS TRANSPORT ROUTE

In comes SGR, which, in time, aims to become a seamless transport route to Uganda and beyond. But that is where the good news ends.

The SGR has been bedraggled in controversy. First, SGR1 from Miritini to Syokimau was notoriously expensive to build.

The project was not subjected to competitive tendering but cobbled together by a cabal of officials from Kenya and China.

The design, construction and operation were not segmented but fused — against standard professional norms. I suspect it contributed to the high cost.

I have no issue with the concept and vision, just the cost — one of the major causes of our surging debt.

A simple cost benefit analysis blurts out the question as to whether the gargantuan investment was worth it and could we not have built it for less?

CONTROVERSIES

Behind the semblance of a smoothly run operation lie several questions and controversies. Its day-to-day operation runs at a considerable loss.

It is important to be clear here: It’s running operation minus the debt repayment per se. Kenya Railways Managing Director Atanus Maina talks about operational viability in three to five years but that could be wishful thinking.

The bottom line is, its operational costs are abnormally high. There are 50 Chinese drivers alone and several hundreds of other Chinese manning the operation at every level and station, all paid by the revenue and subsidies.

If it wasn’t for the station names and the mix of passengers, one could be forgiven for thinking one were in mainland China!

The big and burning question is where to go from here because this project is heading into more controversy and massive debt that will become unsustainable. One controversy is its routing through parts of our precious but embattled Nairobi National Park.

INDEPENDENT BODY

The way forward does not lie with Kenya Railways or China Road and Bridge Corporation (CRBC) nor with any affiliate.

It lies with the government being bold enough ...
Read More

Category: topnews news oped opinion

Suggested

26 minutes
@DailyNation - By: Afp
Why Paris has renamed metro stations

The changes represent "winks" to the team, Paris transport operator RATP said Monday. ...

Category: topnews news sports
1 hour ago
@CITIZENTV - By: Benjamin Muriuki
Obama speaks on corruption in Kenya

Former US President Barack Obama on Monday commended Kenya for the progress that has been realised in the country since 1991 when he toured Kenya for the first time. ...

Category: topnews news
1 hours ago, 14:27
@DailyNation - By: Aggrey Mutambo
Barack Obama urges leaders to tackle graft

Former US President commends Uhuru and Raila for agreeing to work together. ...

Category: topnews news
1 hours ago, 14:29
@TheEastAfrican - By: Njiraini Muchira
Kenya banks ask court for respite over Treasury taxes

Minister can operationalise proposals in the Finance Act for up to 6 months without waiting for MPs to okay the Act. ...

Category: topnews news business
1 hours ago, 14:04
@StandardMedia - By: Silah Koskei
Attacking Raila and Uhuru might deny Ruto presidency, Keter warns

Keter faulted DP Ruto allies for ruining his presidential chances with constant accusations at Raila, Uhuru. ...

Category: topnews news
21 minutes
@TheStar - By: Brian Otieno @yob ...
NASA is dead but I'm not joining Ruto - Wetangula

NASA is dead but I will not join Deputy President William Ruto's camp, Bungoma senator Moses Wetangula has said.Wetang'ula said he has his own house (Ford Kenya) and will build it to make it stronger ...

Category: topnews news
Our App