@TheEastAfrican

Fanon, Rodney and Moyo say Africa’s plight isn't our own fault; I say it is

4 months ago, 9 Aug 16:18

By: Tee Ngugi

Why does Africa fail is a question that has exercised the continent’s best minds since Independence.

In The Wretched of the Earth, a much-loved text of pan-African scholarship, Frantz Fanon theorised that the nationalists who took power were alienated from the people by colonial education and would, therefore, create policies that would perpetuate a neo-colonial relationship between the newly independent states and their former masters.

Subsequent study and experience have demonstrated that Fanon’s psychoanalytical theory of underdevelopment is reductionist and simplistic.

However, in the same book, Fanon warned that attempting to base the new states on pre-colonial traditions, as the nationalists and intellectuals of the Negritude persuasion advocated, would be counterproductive.

In this regard, Fanon’s warning was prescient. Indeed, Fanon argued that the very act of resistance to colonialism was creating a new culture that was the correct foundation for the new African society.

Then there was Walter Rodney, the Guyanese historian and political activist, who in his How Europe Underdeveloped Africa, argued that the colonial powers deliberately underdeveloped Africa, and the relationship of exploiter and exploited would continue to make Africa a supplier of primary goods to fuel Europe’s development.

Rodney advocated a revolutionary dismantling of that relationship. A teacher in the University of Dar es Salaam at the time of the Arusha Declaration, he saw Tanzania’s Ujamaa experiment as a revolutionary effort to restructure the exploitative relationship between coloniser and colonised.

Ujamaa would later collapse. While Rodney’s argument is a great academic contribution to post-colonial African discourse, it too proved to be too constrained by Marxist orthodoxy.

In Dead Aid, Dambisa Moyo blames Africa’s underdevelopment on the debt trap. She asks poignantly: “Why is it that Africa, alone among the continents of the world, seems to be locked in a cycle of dysfunction?”

Unlike Fanon and Rodney, Moyo’s analysis is more realistic, less encumbered by ideological baggage. Her thesis is that Africa borrows then misuses the money, then borrows again, and thus becomes trapped in a vicious cycle of debt dependency.

However, Moyo’s analysis is also reductionist, as she chooses to view Africa’s underdevelopment exclusively through the prism of debt.

These three – the psychoanalytical, the Marxist and the policy-based – are fairly representative of the range of approaches to Africa’s dysfunction puzzle. The deficiency in all three analyses is that they, to various degrees of emphasis, focus on an external source for Africa’s dysfunction.

They fail to emphasise the critical roles played by the three mutually influencing factors of leadership, politics and national culture in defining, shaping and driving a society.

Three recent events have reminded us just how critical leadership, politics and national culture are to the development project. The first is a post doing rounds on social media.

It is about how the Croatian president took leave and paid her own economy ticket to go cheer her national team at the World Cup, while a group of Kenyan MPs, with parliament still in session, travelled first class at taxpayers’ expense to go to the Cup.

The second is the wild, literally frothing-at-the-mouth, vitriol ...
Read More


Category: topnews news oped opinion

Suggested

14 minutes
@CITIZENTV - By: Reuters
Modric criticises Messi, Ronaldo for Ballon d’Or gala snub

Juventus forward Ronaldo came second in the 2018 Ballon d’Or vote behind his old Real team mate Modric, while Messi was fifth, a ranking met with some consternation at both the Argentine’s club Barcel ...

Category: topnews news sports
1 hour ago
@CITIZENTV - By: Reuters
Kenyan warriors hunt cash not lions in Maasai Olympics

Young Kenyan warriors are no longer pursuing lions to show off their hunting prowess and bravery. ...

Category: topnews news
1 hours ago, 11:16
@DailyNation - By: Justus Wanga
Uhuru and I want the best for country, Raila tells Kenyans

Both endorse elections that promote inclusivity. ...

Category: topnews news
1 hours ago, 11:16
@DailyNation - By: Sunday Nation Rep ...
Raila speaks on 'handshake' deal and state of Opposition

He says the USA was not behind the peace deal, that it was purely local. ...

Category: topnews news
1 hour ago
@CapitalFMNews - By: Jeremiah Wakaya
Kenya celebrates wildlife rangers in annual conservation heroes’ day

NAIROBI, Kenya, Dec 16 – Kenya was Sunday set to celebrate rangers tasked with the protection of the country’s wildlife including the famous big five – - Kenya breaking news | Kenya news today | Capit ...

Category: topnews
1 hours ago, 11:16
@DailyNation - By: Ouma Wanzala
Exposed: Loopholes that derailed new curriculum plan

Review process was to cost Sh365bn for first four years, but it was not budgeted for. ...

Category: topnews news

@TheEastAfrican

Fanon, Rodney and Moyo say Africa’s plight isn't our own fault; I say it is

4 months ago, 9 Aug 16:18

By: Tee Ngugi

Why does Africa fail is a question that has exercised the continent’s best minds since Independence.

In The Wretched of the Earth, a much-loved text of pan-African scholarship, Frantz Fanon theorised that the nationalists who took power were alienated from the people by colonial education and would, therefore, create policies that would perpetuate a neo-colonial relationship between the newly independent states and their former masters.

Subsequent study and experience have demonstrated that Fanon’s psychoanalytical theory of underdevelopment is reductionist and simplistic.

However, in the same book, Fanon warned that attempting to base the new states on pre-colonial traditions, as the nationalists and intellectuals of the Negritude persuasion advocated, would be counterproductive.

In this regard, Fanon’s warning was prescient. Indeed, Fanon argued that the very act of resistance to colonialism was creating a new culture that was the correct foundation for the new African society.

Then there was Walter Rodney, the Guyanese historian and political activist, who in his How Europe Underdeveloped Africa, argued that the colonial powers deliberately underdeveloped Africa, and the relationship of exploiter and exploited would continue to make Africa a supplier of primary goods to fuel Europe’s development.

Rodney advocated a revolutionary dismantling of that relationship. A teacher in the University of Dar es Salaam at the time of the Arusha Declaration, he saw Tanzania’s Ujamaa experiment as a revolutionary effort to restructure the exploitative relationship between coloniser and colonised.

Ujamaa would later collapse. While Rodney’s argument is a great academic contribution to post-colonial African discourse, it too proved to be too constrained by Marxist orthodoxy.

In Dead Aid, Dambisa Moyo blames Africa’s underdevelopment on the debt trap. She asks poignantly: “Why is it that Africa, alone among the continents of the world, seems to be locked in a cycle of dysfunction?”

Unlike Fanon and Rodney, Moyo’s analysis is more realistic, less encumbered by ideological baggage. Her thesis is that Africa borrows then misuses the money, then borrows again, and thus becomes trapped in a vicious cycle of debt dependency.

However, Moyo’s analysis is also reductionist, as she chooses to view Africa’s underdevelopment exclusively through the prism of debt.

These three – the psychoanalytical, the Marxist and the policy-based – are fairly representative of the range of approaches to Africa’s dysfunction puzzle. The deficiency in all three analyses is that they, to various degrees of emphasis, focus on an external source for Africa’s dysfunction.

They fail to emphasise the critical roles played by the three mutually influencing factors of leadership, politics and national culture in defining, shaping and driving a society.

Three recent events have reminded us just how critical leadership, politics and national culture are to the development project. The first is a post doing rounds on social media.

It is about how the Croatian president took leave and paid her own economy ticket to go cheer her national team at the World Cup, while a group of Kenyan MPs, with parliament still in session, travelled first class at taxpayers’ expense to go to the Cup.

The second is the wild, literally frothing-at-the-mouth, vitriol ...
Read More

Category: topnews news oped opinion

Suggested

14 minutes
@CITIZENTV - By: Reuters
Modric criticises Messi, Ronaldo for Ballon d’Or gala snub

Juventus forward Ronaldo came second in the 2018 Ballon d’Or vote behind his old Real team mate Modric, while Messi was fifth, a ranking met with some consternation at both the Argentine’s club Barcel ...

Category: topnews news sports
1 hour ago
@CITIZENTV - By: Reuters
Kenyan warriors hunt cash not lions in Maasai Olympics

Young Kenyan warriors are no longer pursuing lions to show off their hunting prowess and bravery. ...

Category: topnews news
1 hours ago, 11:16
@DailyNation - By: Justus Wanga
Uhuru and I want the best for country, Raila tells Kenyans

Both endorse elections that promote inclusivity. ...

Category: topnews news
1 hours ago, 11:16
@DailyNation - By: Sunday Nation Rep ...
Raila speaks on 'handshake' deal and state of Opposition

He says the USA was not behind the peace deal, that it was purely local. ...

Category: topnews news
1 hour ago
@CapitalFMNews - By: Jeremiah Wakaya
Kenya celebrates wildlife rangers in annual conservation heroes’ day

NAIROBI, Kenya, Dec 16 – Kenya was Sunday set to celebrate rangers tasked with the protection of the country’s wildlife including the famous big five – - Kenya breaking news | Kenya news today | Capit ...

Category: topnews
1 hours ago, 11:16
@DailyNation - By: Ouma Wanzala
Exposed: Loopholes that derailed new curriculum plan

Review process was to cost Sh365bn for first four years, but it was not budgeted for. ...

Category: topnews news
Our App