@BusinessDaily

Court dismisses Sh26mn KRA tax demand from importer

6 days ago, 13:26

By: Philip Muyanga

The Kenya Revenue Authority (KRA) has suffered a setback after a decision to demand Sh26.2 million from a rice importer was dismissed.

The taxman had claimed uncollected duty from a firm, Krish Commodities Ltd, as a result of the application of a lower duty rate.

The Court of Appeal in Mombasa also prohibited KRA from continuing to demand money from the company in respect of importation of rice cleared by the taxman.

Krish Commodities Ltd had moved to the Appellate Court after the High Court dismissed its application seeking to have demands by KRA quashed. Judges Alnashir Visram, Wanjiru Karanja and Martha Koome said the High Court erred in its discretion.

“We set aside the judgment and substitute the same with an order allowing Krish Commodities Ltd application,” said the three judge appellate bench.

They also noted that identification of applicable rate of duty and assessment of what was payable was done by the Simba System previously used by KRA for customs processing.

“The appellant had no role in declaring or setting the rate to be applied, for KRA to turn around and pass the buck to the company by contending that it was aware of the right rate cannot hold any weight,” ruled the judges.

The court was told that the company had in 2008 and 2009 imported rice into the country and the consignments cleared.

Later in 2011, it received a letter from KRA demanding payment of short levied duty over the goods.

The court also heard that the underpayment arose from the application of the wrong duty rate during the clearance and assessment of duty payable.

Through lawyer Sanjeev Khagram, the company argued among other issues that the High Court erred in failing to appreciate the circumstances under which Simba System assessed the duty payable over imported goods.

Mr Khagram further argued that having paid the duty assessed, it was unfair for KRA to try and impose the alleged short levied sugar four years’ later taking into consideration that the purported erroneous application of the wrong rate of duty was attributable to the taxman.

KRA, through lawyer Pius Nyaga, argued that it conducted a post clearance audit on the consignment of rice imported by the company.

Mr Nyaga said the results revealed that the wrong duty of 35 per cent had been used in computing the duty payable for the consignment.

He further argued that the Kenyan tax system is based on self-accounting and assessment since everyone is supposed to make a declaration of how much tax is due and payable and KRA is empowered to audit the declarations.


Read More


Category: business opinion news markets economy corporate

Suggested

2 hours ago, 12:29
@TheEastAfrican - By: James Anyanzwa
Brokers hand over NSE to foreigners as falling returns keep Kenyans away

The stockmarket is now exposed to the risk of a price dip in the event of panic sales. ...

Category: topnews news business
3 hours ago, 12:04
@CITIZENTV - By: Daniel Korir
Rift MPs call for release of maize farmers’ pay

Rift MPs call for release of maize farmers' pay ...

Category: topnews news business
3 hours ago, 12:04
@CITIZENTV - By: Kepha Muiruri
Blockchain taskforce mulls regulated digital currency

Blockchain taskforce mulls regulated digital currency ...

Category: business topnews news
2 hours ago, 12:34
@StandardMedia - By: Fredrick Obura
Kenya Power allays fear of service interruption despite senior staff probe

Kenya Power has moved to assure stakeholders and public of uninterrupted services despite on-going probe on senior management staff. ...

Category: business news
32 minutes
@StandardMedia - By: George Farrel Ogol ...
Huduma centre launches shift working programme

Huduma Centre will operate in two shifts to ensure longer working hours. ...

Category: business news
Now
@StandardMedia - By: Mercy Kahenda
Maize farmers yet to receive pay despite government promise

South Rift farmers are yet to receive payments for their produce delivered to the National Cereal and Produce Board (NCPB) several months ago ...

Category: business news

@BusinessDaily

Court dismisses Sh26mn KRA tax demand from importer

6 days ago, 13:26

By: Philip Muyanga

The Kenya Revenue Authority (KRA) has suffered a setback after a decision to demand Sh26.2 million from a rice importer was dismissed.

The taxman had claimed uncollected duty from a firm, Krish Commodities Ltd, as a result of the application of a lower duty rate.

The Court of Appeal in Mombasa also prohibited KRA from continuing to demand money from the company in respect of importation of rice cleared by the taxman.

Krish Commodities Ltd had moved to the Appellate Court after the High Court dismissed its application seeking to have demands by KRA quashed. Judges Alnashir Visram, Wanjiru Karanja and Martha Koome said the High Court erred in its discretion.

“We set aside the judgment and substitute the same with an order allowing Krish Commodities Ltd application,” said the three judge appellate bench.

They also noted that identification of applicable rate of duty and assessment of what was payable was done by the Simba System previously used by KRA for customs processing.

“The appellant had no role in declaring or setting the rate to be applied, for KRA to turn around and pass the buck to the company by contending that it was aware of the right rate cannot hold any weight,” ruled the judges.

The court was told that the company had in 2008 and 2009 imported rice into the country and the consignments cleared.

Later in 2011, it received a letter from KRA demanding payment of short levied duty over the goods.

The court also heard that the underpayment arose from the application of the wrong duty rate during the clearance and assessment of duty payable.

Through lawyer Sanjeev Khagram, the company argued among other issues that the High Court erred in failing to appreciate the circumstances under which Simba System assessed the duty payable over imported goods.

Mr Khagram further argued that having paid the duty assessed, it was unfair for KRA to try and impose the alleged short levied sugar four years’ later taking into consideration that the purported erroneous application of the wrong rate of duty was attributable to the taxman.

KRA, through lawyer Pius Nyaga, argued that it conducted a post clearance audit on the consignment of rice imported by the company.

Mr Nyaga said the results revealed that the wrong duty of 35 per cent had been used in computing the duty payable for the consignment.

He further argued that the Kenyan tax system is based on self-accounting and assessment since everyone is supposed to make a declaration of how much tax is due and payable and KRA is empowered to audit the declarations.


Read More

Category: business opinion news markets economy corporate

Suggested

2 hours ago, 12:29
@TheEastAfrican - By: James Anyanzwa
Brokers hand over NSE to foreigners as falling returns keep Kenyans away

The stockmarket is now exposed to the risk of a price dip in the event of panic sales. ...

Category: topnews news business
3 hours ago, 12:04
@CITIZENTV - By: Daniel Korir
Rift MPs call for release of maize farmers’ pay

Rift MPs call for release of maize farmers' pay ...

Category: topnews news business
3 hours ago, 12:04
@CITIZENTV - By: Kepha Muiruri
Blockchain taskforce mulls regulated digital currency

Blockchain taskforce mulls regulated digital currency ...

Category: business topnews news
2 hours ago, 12:34
@StandardMedia - By: Fredrick Obura
Kenya Power allays fear of service interruption despite senior staff probe

Kenya Power has moved to assure stakeholders and public of uninterrupted services despite on-going probe on senior management staff. ...

Category: business news
32 minutes
@StandardMedia - By: George Farrel Ogol ...
Huduma centre launches shift working programme

Huduma Centre will operate in two shifts to ensure longer working hours. ...

Category: business news
Now
@StandardMedia - By: Mercy Kahenda
Maize farmers yet to receive pay despite government promise

South Rift farmers are yet to receive payments for their produce delivered to the National Cereal and Produce Board (NCPB) several months ago ...

Category: business news
Our App