@NairobiNews

BLOG: Cambridge Analytica's role in Kenya elections has been overstated - Nairobi News

6 months ago, 2 Apr 11:30

By: Gabrielle Lynch,

Election manipulation is a hot story. In the last few days, Cambridge Analytica, which claims to use data to change behaviour including that of voters, has been accused of breaching Facebook rules in its efforts to collect personal data and use them to bring Donald Trump to power.

Cambridge Analytica is accused of interfering in elections on a very broad canvas. In Nigeria, it’s said to have used underhand tactics to try and secure the re-election of then President Goodluck Jonathan in 2015.

Allegations in Kenya have focused on claims that Cambridge Analytica helped president Uhuru Kenyatta to retain power in 2017 by designing divisive campaigns that demonised opposition candidate Raila Odinga, bringing the country closer to civil conflict.

But caution is required, at least when it comes to the stories about interference in Nigeria and Kenya. The company’s impact has in fact been massively exaggerated as a result of claims made by Cambridge Analytica itself.

Speaking about the campaign of Kenyatta’s Jubilee Party, managing director Mark Turnbull has been caught on camera claiming to have “staged the whole thing”. Unsurprisingly, given the willingness of employees of the firm to talk about the use of underhand strategies such as honey traps and fake news, opposition leaders are up in arms. National Super Alliance official Norman Magaya has called for a full investigation into Cambridge Analytica’s role, accusing it, and the ruling party, of trying to subvert the people’s will.

But while such investigations need to be conducted and questions raised by the opposition need to be answered, we should also ask a prior question: can Cambridge Analytica deliver on its claims?

The evidence from Africa is no.

This is not to say that Cambridge Analytica doesn’t present a threat to democracy, or that it should not be ashamed of itself or face investigation. But it is to say that its impact in Africa has been over-hyped because it serves a variety of interests to do so.

Failures in Nigeria and Kenya

In Nigeria, the company was brought in to save President Jonathan by wealthy supporters desperate for him to stay in power.

It failed. In the 2015 elections, Jonathan became the first ever Nigerian leader to lose at the ballot box. In fact he didn’t only lose. He was soundly beaten by an opposition party competing with one hand tied behind its back in a political system that conferred massive advantages of incumbency.

There are also reasons to think that the company’s impact has been overstated in Kenya. It is true that Kenyatta was eventually declared the winner of the election – though the first contest was nullified by the Supreme Court for procedural irregularities and the opposition did not take part in the re-run – but there is little evidence that Cambridge Analytica’s much vaunted ability to manipulate “big data” was the reason for this.

Take the question of targeted social media campaigns. It is true that material was circulated attacking Odinga as a dangerous and irresponsible leader. Cambridge Analytica may have advised the government to adopt this strategy – although ...
Read More


Category: blogs news

Suggested

2 weeks ago, 13:51
@NairobiNews - By: Nairobi Wife
MEN: You can only have one of these; home maker or career woman - Nairobi News

I have been having serious arguments with colleagues and friends on the priorities people should have in life. ...

Category: blogs news
2 weeks ago, 08:07
@NairobiNews - By: Njoki Chege
CITY GIRL: Young girls, forget easy money, be safe - Nairobi News

There are few topics I avoid writing about, and one of them is that on “sponsors”. I shun mainly because I highly disagree with the “sponsorship philosophy.” ...

Category: news blogs
2 weeks ago, 15:34
@NairobiNews - By: Nairobi Wife
WEDDING ANNIVERSARY: My two years of marriage have been truly awesome - Nairobi News

My husband and I celebrated our second wedding anniversary earlier this week. It’s a great feeling, knowing that we have survived year two without killing each other. ...

Category: news blogs
2 weeks ago, 16:01
@NairobiNews - By: Jo Paying
Brothers, let that she go, if you can't pay the bill! - Nairobi News

This is a pure mockery to the masculine nature, if you cannot afford Sankara save up for it. Brothers, if you cannot keep up, do not subject yourself to ulcers, let that she go. ...

Category: blogs news
2 weeks ago, 08:01
@NairobiNews - By: Njoki Chege
CITY GIRL: Want to steer clear of cults? Here are the ways - Nairobi News

Anecdotal evidence suggests that victims of cults masquerading as churches are not necessarily the uneducated or the under-exposed as we have wrongly thought all along. ...

Category: news blogs
1 months ago, 25 Aug 09:50
@NairobiNews - By: Nairobi Wife
LIVING: Young people, just do you; whatever makes you happy - Nairobi News

When I was going away to the university to pursue my degree, of all the advice I got, the very best was from my aunt who kept it real with me. ...

Category: lifestyle news blogs

@NairobiNews

BLOG: Cambridge Analytica's role in Kenya elections has been overstated - Nairobi News

6 months ago, 2 Apr 11:30

By: Gabrielle Lynch,

Election manipulation is a hot story. In the last few days, Cambridge Analytica, which claims to use data to change behaviour including that of voters, has been accused of breaching Facebook rules in its efforts to collect personal data and use them to bring Donald Trump to power.

Cambridge Analytica is accused of interfering in elections on a very broad canvas. In Nigeria, it’s said to have used underhand tactics to try and secure the re-election of then President Goodluck Jonathan in 2015.

Allegations in Kenya have focused on claims that Cambridge Analytica helped president Uhuru Kenyatta to retain power in 2017 by designing divisive campaigns that demonised opposition candidate Raila Odinga, bringing the country closer to civil conflict.

But caution is required, at least when it comes to the stories about interference in Nigeria and Kenya. The company’s impact has in fact been massively exaggerated as a result of claims made by Cambridge Analytica itself.

Speaking about the campaign of Kenyatta’s Jubilee Party, managing director Mark Turnbull has been caught on camera claiming to have “staged the whole thing”. Unsurprisingly, given the willingness of employees of the firm to talk about the use of underhand strategies such as honey traps and fake news, opposition leaders are up in arms. National Super Alliance official Norman Magaya has called for a full investigation into Cambridge Analytica’s role, accusing it, and the ruling party, of trying to subvert the people’s will.

But while such investigations need to be conducted and questions raised by the opposition need to be answered, we should also ask a prior question: can Cambridge Analytica deliver on its claims?

The evidence from Africa is no.

This is not to say that Cambridge Analytica doesn’t present a threat to democracy, or that it should not be ashamed of itself or face investigation. But it is to say that its impact in Africa has been over-hyped because it serves a variety of interests to do so.

Failures in Nigeria and Kenya

In Nigeria, the company was brought in to save President Jonathan by wealthy supporters desperate for him to stay in power.

It failed. In the 2015 elections, Jonathan became the first ever Nigerian leader to lose at the ballot box. In fact he didn’t only lose. He was soundly beaten by an opposition party competing with one hand tied behind its back in a political system that conferred massive advantages of incumbency.

There are also reasons to think that the company’s impact has been overstated in Kenya. It is true that Kenyatta was eventually declared the winner of the election – though the first contest was nullified by the Supreme Court for procedural irregularities and the opposition did not take part in the re-run – but there is little evidence that Cambridge Analytica’s much vaunted ability to manipulate “big data” was the reason for this.

Take the question of targeted social media campaigns. It is true that material was circulated attacking Odinga as a dangerous and irresponsible leader. Cambridge Analytica may have advised the government to adopt this strategy – although ...
Read More

Category: blogs news

Suggested

2 weeks ago, 13:51
@NairobiNews - By: Nairobi Wife
MEN: You can only have one of these; home maker or career woman - Nairobi News

I have been having serious arguments with colleagues and friends on the priorities people should have in life. ...

Category: blogs news
2 weeks ago, 08:07
@NairobiNews - By: Njoki Chege
CITY GIRL: Young girls, forget easy money, be safe - Nairobi News

There are few topics I avoid writing about, and one of them is that on “sponsors”. I shun mainly because I highly disagree with the “sponsorship philosophy.” ...

Category: news blogs
2 weeks ago, 15:34
@NairobiNews - By: Nairobi Wife
WEDDING ANNIVERSARY: My two years of marriage have been truly awesome - Nairobi News

My husband and I celebrated our second wedding anniversary earlier this week. It’s a great feeling, knowing that we have survived year two without killing each other. ...

Category: news blogs
2 weeks ago, 16:01
@NairobiNews - By: Jo Paying
Brothers, let that she go, if you can't pay the bill! - Nairobi News

This is a pure mockery to the masculine nature, if you cannot afford Sankara save up for it. Brothers, if you cannot keep up, do not subject yourself to ulcers, let that she go. ...

Category: blogs news
2 weeks ago, 08:01
@NairobiNews - By: Njoki Chege
CITY GIRL: Want to steer clear of cults? Here are the ways - Nairobi News

Anecdotal evidence suggests that victims of cults masquerading as churches are not necessarily the uneducated or the under-exposed as we have wrongly thought all along. ...

Category: news blogs
1 months ago, 25 Aug 09:50
@NairobiNews - By: Nairobi Wife
LIVING: Young people, just do you; whatever makes you happy - Nairobi News

When I was going away to the university to pursue my degree, of all the advice I got, the very best was from my aunt who kept it real with me. ...

Category: lifestyle news blogs
Our App